top of page

Ernie Ball Strap Locks vs Schaller: Is The Under $20 Item A Better Choice Than The Over $20 One?

When you are performing with your guitar, you more than likely will want to be standing. To stand you need a strap, and when you have a strap you want to be able to get it off an on easily. That's where strap locks come into play. We decided to do a quick comparison of the nickel strap lock buttons between ernie ball and schaller. First let's take a look at both items before analysis.


Below are the Ernie Ball nickel strap locks. Currently going for $19.99 on Amazon and they have a 4.8 star score on over 1100 ratings.

Ernie Ball Super Locks, Nickel

Below are the Schaller nickel strap locks. Currently going for $25.68 on Amazon and they have a 4.8 star score on over 1700 ratings.

Schaller S Locks Guitar Strap Locks and Buttons (Pair) Nickel

Right off the bat we are seeing comparable feedback. Both products are at 4.8 which are great scores. Both products pass the Review Meta analysis so good news there as well. On face it is looking like Ernie Ball at the very least can hold its own against the Schaller for over $5 less.


So let's go to Chat GPT to see if the AI can see anything we might have missed.


"Both Ernie Ball and Schaller are reputable brands that offer high-quality strap locks for guitars. The primary purpose of strap locks is to securely attach your guitar strap to your instrument, preventing it from accidentally coming off while playing. Let's compare Ernie Ball and Schaller strap locks based on some key factors:

  1. Design and Installation: Both brands offer various designs of strap locks, with slight differences in how they attach to the guitar. Ernie Ball's strap locks are generally easy to install and use a push-button mechanism to release the strap. Schaller strap locks also offer straightforward installation and a locking mechanism that involves twisting the lock to attach or release the strap.

  2. Durability: Both brands are known for producing durable and reliable products. The durability of strap locks largely depends on the materials used and the construction. Both Ernie Ball and Schaller strap locks are made from robust materials like metal, ensuring they can withstand the demands of live performances and regular use.

  3. Compatibility: Both Ernie Ball and Schaller strap locks are designed to be compatible with most standard strap buttons on guitars. However, it's always a good idea to double-check the compatibility with your specific guitar model before making a purchase.

  4. Variety: Both brands offer a range of options in terms of design, finish, and materials. You can choose the style that best matches your guitar's aesthetics and your personal preferences.

  5. Price: The prices of strap locks from Ernie Ball and Schaller can vary depending on the specific model and finish you choose. Generally, they are priced reasonably and offer good value for the added security they provide.

  6. User Feedback: User experiences can vary, but both Ernie Ball and Schaller strap locks tend to receive positive reviews for their functionality and reliability.

In the end, the choice between Ernie Ball and Schaller strap locks often comes down to personal preference. Some guitarists might prefer the design or installation process of one over the other. It's a good idea to try both if possible or read reviews from other musicians who have used these strap locks on similar guitars to get a better sense of which might be the best fit for you."


Very nice, so it looks like Ernie Ball passes the AI test as well. If you are looking for strap buttons under $20, Ernie Ball looks like a good pick.


NOTE: All price and review info is based on the time of posting. The numbers may have changed since the creation of this article. Don't forget to always research everything yourself before you buy it, don't just take our word for it. All links to Amazon on this page are part of the Associates program which gives us commissions, thanks for your support!


bottom of page