top of page

Gloves In A Bottle vs Working Hands: What Are The Key Differences? We Ask Chat GPT

Your skin likes it when you take care of it. The world is harsh on the skin. Working, weather, crazy people, etc... you never know what could make your skin dry and cracked. Luckily there are products out there to help you heal it. We have two listings to look at, Gloves In A Bottle and O'Keefe's working hands. Let's take a look at the products and then kick it to Chat GPT.

Below is a 3.4 oz tube of Gloves In A Bottle which I will call GIAB from now on for simplicity. Currently on Amazon for $13.73 and it has a 4.3 star score on over 9,600 ratings.

Gloves In A Bottle – Shielding Lotion for Dry Skin, Hand Lotion Travel Size, Protects & Restores Dry Cracked Skin– 3.4 oz..

Then we have the working hands cream by O'keefe's. Currently on Amazon for $9.02 for a jar of 3.4 oz and it has a 4.7 star score on over 71,000 ratings.

O'Keeffe's Working Hands Hand Cream, 3.4 oz., Jar

On stats alone working hands has the edge in price, score, and ratings. Let's see if Chat GPT has something more they can clue us in about...

"Gloves in a Bottle and Working Hands are both popular hand care products, each with its own unique features and benefits.

  • Gloves In A Bottle: This product is a shielding lotion that bonds with the outermost layer of skin cells to create an invisible barrier. This barrier helps to lock in moisture and prevent the loss of natural oils and moisture from the skin. It's particularly beneficial for people who frequently wash their hands or work with harsh chemicals, as it provides protection against irritation and dryness. Gloves In A Bottle is often recommended by dermatologists and is suitable for various skin conditions like eczema, psoriasis, and dermatitis.

  • Working Hands: Working Hands is a hand cream specifically designed to moisturize and repair dry, cracked skin. It's formulated with ingredients like glycerin and allantoin, which are known for their moisturizing and healing properties. This product is especially popular among people who work with their hands in rough conditions or environments that can lead to dryness and irritation, such as construction workers, gardeners, and healthcare professionals. Working Hands absorbs quickly into the skin without leaving a greasy residue and provides long-lasting hydration.

Both products have their own strengths and can be effective solutions for dry, rough, or irritated hands. The choice between them may depend on personal preferences, skin type, specific needs, and the severity of the skin condition. Some individuals may find that one product works better for them than the other, so it can be helpful to try both and see which one provides the desired results. Additionally, consulting with a dermatologist can offer personalized recommendations based on individual skin concerns."

So interesting analysis by the AI. It does appear that there is one key difference between the two products. GIAB appears to be more of a product that is meant to prevent damage where as working hands is more about repairing when the damage is done. It's a sort of proactive vs reactive thing. In the end both products look good and will probably do a good job for you. That said if it matters how you want to heal your hands then go with GIAB if you want to have more of a protective layer and go with working hands if you are fine with taking damage as long as you can repair it later.

NOTE: All price and review info is based on the time of posting. The numbers may have changed since the creation of this article. Don't forget to always research everything yourself before you buy it, don't just take our word for it. All links to Amazon on this page are part of the Associates program which gives us commissions, thanks for your support!


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page