top of page

Mesh vs Plastic Shower Caddy: What Are The Key Differences? We Ask Chat GPT

Ok so you need to take a shower. The only issue is that it's not your own personal shower and you have to share it with other people. So that means you have to carry your shower stuff in and out every time. If that is the case, then that means you'll need a caddy. Of course the question then becomes what should you go for? Plastic or mesh? Well Chat GPT has some insight for us. Before we get to that let's take a look at the picks we went with.


First we have a mesh caddy. We went with Amazon's overall pick for it which is the caddy from Eudele. It is currently on Amazon for $8.99 and it has a 4.7 star score on over 6,700 ratings.

Mesh Shower Caddy Portable for College Dorm Room Essentials,Shower Caddy Dorm with 8-Pocket Large Capacity for Beach,Swimming,Gym,Travel essentials

Next we have the overall Amazon pick for the plastic caddy. From Uujoly it is currently on Amazon for $14.99 and it has a 4.6 star score on over 850 ratings.


UUJOLY Plastic Portable Shower Caddy Basket Bucket, Cleaning Shower Basket with Handle Compartments Storage Basket Organizer for Bathroom Kitchen College Dorm Sink, Grey

Now of course there are a ton of options under $20 for both mesh and plastic. We just decided to go with these since they are the overall picks from Amazon. Now let's take a look at what Chat GPT has to say...


"When choosing between a plastic and a mesh shower caddy, there are several factors to consider:


  • Durability: Plastic shower caddies are typically more durable and long-lasting compared to mesh caddies. They are less prone to tearing or damage from water exposure. If you're looking for something that will last a long time, a plastic caddy might be the better option.

  • Water Resistance: Plastic caddies are inherently water-resistant, while mesh caddies allow water to drain through easily. If you're concerned about water pooling in your caddy or items getting wet, a mesh caddy might be preferable as it allows for better drainage.

  • Visibility and Ventilation: Mesh caddies provide better visibility of the items stored inside and offer more ventilation, which can help prevent mildew and odors from developing. If you prefer to see your items clearly and want better airflow, a mesh caddy would be a good choice.

  • Weight: Mesh caddies are generally lighter than plastic caddies, which can be advantageous if you need to carry your caddy frequently or if you're concerned about the weight of your shower accessories.

  • Aesthetics: Plastic caddies come in a variety of colors and designs, while mesh caddies typically have a simpler, more utilitarian appearance. Your choice may depend on your personal style preferences and the overall aesthetic of your bathroom.

  • Cleaning and Maintenance: Both plastic and mesh caddies are relatively easy to clean, but mesh caddies may require more frequent cleaning to prevent mold and mildew buildup due to their porous nature.


In summary, if durability and water resistance are your top priorities, a plastic shower caddy may be the better option. However, if you prefer better visibility, ventilation, and lightweight design, a mesh shower caddy could be more suitable for your needs. Ultimately, your choice will depend on your specific preferences and requirements."


Really good breakdown. That analysis also appears in the price. The mesh caddies do appear to be cheaper. Then again, if they break down faster you may end up spending more in the long run so choose wisely.


NOTE: All price and review info is based on the time of posting. The numbers may have changed since the creation of this article. Don't forget to always research everything yourself before you buy it, don't just take our word for it. All links to Amazon on this page are part of the Associates program which gives us commissions, thanks for your support!


bottom of page