top of page

V-Cut Cigar Cutter vs Guillotine: Which One Should You Go With? We Ask Chat GPT

One thing you know you need to do before you smoke a cigar is to cut the end off of it. How do you cut it though? Well that is more up for debate. There are two common types of cutters. A V-Cut style and a guillotine style. Which one should you get? We'll ask Chat GPT to see what it thinks. First of course let's show two examples of what we are talking about.

Below is an example of a V-Cut cigar cutter. This one from Mantello is available on Amazon for only $14.99 and it has a 4.6 star score on over 1400 ratings.

Mantello V-Cut Cigar Cutter

Below is an example of a guillotine cutter. This one from Alaska Bear is on Amazon for only $9.95 and it has a 4.6 star score on over 10,000 ratings.

Alaska Bear Guillotine Cigar cutter

Now that we have that out of the way, let's see what Chat GPT thinks.

"Both the V-cut cigar cutter and the guillotine cutter are popular tools used by cigar enthusiasts to cut the cap of a cigar before smoking it. Each type of cutter offers a slightly different experience, and the choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference.

  1. V-Cut Cigar Cutter: A V-cut cutter creates a V-shaped notch in the cap of the cigar. This type of cut is often preferred for cigars with larger ring gauges because it can prevent unraveling and provide a slightly different draw compared to other cuts. The V-cut can offer a concentrated channel for the smoke to pass through, potentially intensifying the flavors and delivering a more controlled draw.


  • Suitable for cigars with larger ring gauges.

  • Prevents the cap from unraveling.

  • May enhance flavors by channeling smoke through a smaller opening.


  • Might not work as well for cigars with very small ring gauges.

  • Some people prefer a different draw style.

  1. Guillotine Cigar Cutter: The guillotine cutter is a straight-edge cutter that snips off the entire cap of the cigar in one motion. There are single-blade and double-blade guillotine cutters, the latter often considered to provide a cleaner cut.


  • Suitable for a wide range of cigar sizes and shapes.

  • Provides a clean, even cut.

  • Familiar and easy to use.


  • Depending on the cut, the cap might unravel over time.

  • The straight cut might expose more of the filler leaves, potentially leading to loose tobacco in the mouth.

Ultimately, the choice between a V-cut and a guillotine cut comes down to your personal preference and the type of smoking experience you're looking for. Some cigar enthusiasts enjoy experimenting with both types of cuts to see how they impact the draw, flavor, and overall smoking experience of different cigars. It's also worth considering the size and shape of the cigar you're smoking, as this can influence which type of cutter works best."

Thanks Chat GPT! You once again have come in the clutch to help us answer the questions that we have.

If you want to see more v-cutters under $20 click here -

If you want to see more guillotine cutters under $20 click here -

NOTE: All price and review info is based on the time of posting. The numbers may have changed since the creation of this article. Don't forget to always research everything yourself before you buy it, don't just take our word for it. All links to Amazon on this page are part of the Associates program which gives us commissions, thanks for your support!


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page